|
In this issue:
ESACT prepares
for Medical Biotechnology Section
EU reinforces
genome research
Genome mouse finished
On the web
FP 5 - New Workprogramme 2001
Industry trends
in biotechnology
Some more predictions
The future of genomics in Europe
Regulatory
news:
embryonic cells
certification TSE risk products
speedier approval procedures
Research news:
in utero immunization
success for alpha-glucosidase
gene knock out with laser pulse
dwindling support for plant research
tomato antigen vaccine
Business news:
delays implementation biotech patenting directive
patent application withdrawn
4C: high cell density bioreactor
Agenda
ESACT
prepares for section Medical Biotechnology
The European Federation of Biotechnology
(www.efbweb.org) is creating larger sections than the earlier
working parties, pushing for improved links to industry and academia
and devising ways of interlinking with cross national societies
like ESACT. As a result of the closer rapprochement of late,
ESACT has been preparing the ground for a Medical Biotechnology
Section, whose main aim is to foster faster moves in Europe to
push products and processes from biotechnology to clinical utilisation;
a key component of such a section is, of course, to have members
which are clinician practitioners. Working together with EFB
and ESGT, a Steering Committee which met in Frankfurt last February,
proposed a workshop entitled “From Medical Development
to Clinical Practices” conducted under the aegis of the
European Commission External Advisory Group “Cell Factory”
which took place in Brussels last June; the report conclusions
and summary can be consulted in (http://forum.europa.eu.int).
This allowed ESACT to invite
some of the clinical participants to become members of the Medical
Biotechnology Section. So, now, the Section seems ready to take
off. ACTIP and ESACT members are invited to contact the ESACT
Secretariat should they wish to become a member.
EU
reinforces genome research
On November 15 last, the European
Commision has launched an initiative to reinforce European activities
in genome research related to human health. Genome research is
strategically important for Europe as it is expected to unlock
considerable economic, medical and social benefits. The development
of new genome-based technologies, as well as new bioinformatics
tools, is of primary importance for competitive genome research
and for the development of new diagnostics and new therapeutic
approaches. It is also important to create and maintain in Europe
infrastructures to support genome research (for example, databases
and animal model resources).
On 8 November, the Commission
services and Member States experts agreed:
* to create a Forum of Genome Research Managers;
* to develop synergies between the Community programme and national
activities, and
* to help network national programmes.
A European Genome Area
The Commission initiative on
Genome Research for Human Health has two main features:
(1) to create a new type of project,
the integrated project; and
(2) to strengthen the support for research infrastructures.
Other features of the initiative
include a reinforcement of research into the ethical implications
and societal impact of genome information. It is expected that
in 2001 over EURO 100 million in total will be available for
this initiative.
Integrated Projects
Integrated projects are designed
to stimulate progress in functional genomics
relating to human health, by creating projects with critical
mass, high impact
and high visibility. Each project should comprise a minimum of
150
researcher-years. It will have three components: research, networking,
and
training and mobility within an integrated management structure.
The research component is expected to achieve groundbreaking
advances on methods
and technologies in functional genomics. The networking component
will allow
the project to act as a federating force in the field, creating
synergy with
and between national research efforts. The training and mobility
component
should provide opportunities to train young researchers at Europe's
top
research centres in the field.
Integrated projects will be selected
by a novel procedure that involves a preliminary call for expressions
of interest for topics that may be suitable for such support
(deadline 9 February 2001). From these, a limited number of topics
of strategic importance will be selected and these will be invited
to submit under a dedicated call for proposals from which the
integrated projects will be selected. This
dedicated call will be published in early summer 2001 (deadline
18 October
2001). The call for proposals and an explanatory memorandum are
available from the ACTIP Secretariat.
Source: Press Release European
Commission, 15-11; www.cordis.lu/life
Manuel Hallen, Quality of
Life programme, Research DG. Tel : +32.2.295.74.07, E-mail manuel.hallen@cec.eu.int
Genome mouse
finished
Mid October, Celera Genomics
announced that 95% of the DNA of the mouse has been sequenced.
Again, Celera beats a public-private consortium (the Mouse Sequencing
Consortium) to the finish.
Source: Bionieuws Oct 28, 2000
On the web
The most up to date genome information,
freely available from:
www.nature.com/genomics
An incredible amount of information
and useful links can be found on the site of the Craig Venter
created TIGR, the not for profit sequencing center:
http://igweb.integratedgenomics.com/GOLD
And for something completely
different, namely art in the genetic age, visit:
www.geneart.org
New
Work Programme 2001 !!
On November 15, 2000, the new
FP5 Work Programme 2001, covering the Quality of Life Pogramme,
was published. The programme has been adopted on several places
to new developments in technology. Most notable is the emphasis
given to genome research. Furthermore, there is
*reinforcement of the socio-economic objectives;
* clear guidelines of support for clinical trials (only support
through demonstration projects, freeing budget for real RTD projects);
* reinforcement of demonstration projects;
* a separate paragraph for accompanying measures.
Emphasis on Genome Research
As part of the Commisson initiative
on the European Genome Area (see above), genome research will
be a research priority in Key Actions, generic RTD programmes
and infrastructures. Integrated project on genomics and human
health, will be accommodated under a new key action iten, Key
Action 8.5. The call for an expression of interest has recently
been issued.
Furthermore, in area 14 references have been included to genomic
and proteomic databases and repositories of animal models.
Reinforcement demonstration
projects
The Commission would like to
see a strengthening of demonstration projects. Demonstration
projects will be open in all Key Actions, but note:
there will not be any RTD projects
but only demonstration projects in areas:
KA 3.1.1. Development of new diagnostics;
KA 3.2.1. New bioprocesses;
KA 3.3.2. High value added products
If you contemplate submitting a proposal for a demonstration
project, carefully read the guide for proposers and the weighing
of evaluation criteria (the weighing of criteria is different
for RTD projects and demonstration projects).
Calls for proposals
As already mentioned, a separate
call for expression of interest in genome research has recently
been issued. There will also be a separate joint call of the
Quality of Life and Environment programmes on endocrine disruptors.
Last date for FP5: October
2001
As for the 'regular' call for
proposals, the deadlines of October 10, 2001 and March 2002 will
be fused, since projects starting late in 2002 would hardly have
2 years to run. Thus, please note that October 10, 2001 will
be the ultimate date that projects can be submitted for FP5 under
dedicated calls for proposals.
Deadlines (last chances!)
The following deadlines have
been set for Key Actions that might be of interest to the membership:
KA 1. Food, nutrition and
health:
3.1. Promoting and sustaining health, including toxicology: March
15, 2001
KA 2. Infectious diseases:
All areas open, but clinical testing only as demonstration projects.
Deadline: October 2001
KA 3. Cell Factory
Deadline of March 15, 2001 for:
3.1.2. Therapeutic substances
3.1.4. Novel in vitro testing systems
3.3.3. Functional biomolecules
Deadline of October 18, 2001:
3.1.1. New diagnostics (demonstration projects only!)
3.1.3.
KA 4. Environment and health
4.2.2. Improvement predictive toxicity testing: March 15, 2001
KA 6. Ageing population
All areas: deadline March 15, 2001
Generic research
All areas. Deadline October 18, 2001
Fellowships:
Deadlines April 11, October 10, 2001
Accompanying measures:
Deadlines February 9, June 12, October 11, 2001
Industry
trends in biotechnology
The Nature Biotechnology Volume
18 supplement October 2000 is entirely devoted to Industry Trends
in Biotechnology. It containes snapshots of industry's fastest
moving fields. The selection of topics includes some of the hottest
areas and issues in biotechnology. The content focuses mainly
on technology platforms and disease areas, and each article refers
to companies active in the fields mentioned.
In the area of diseases, some
of the biggest killers and debilitators have been included. According
to estimates of the editor, the total disease burden, both in
direct and indirect costs, of the eight diseases covered amounts
to a staggering $ 500 billion. Nevertheless, all of these diseases
are manageble today. Several articles cover many of the technology
platforms offered by biotechnology companies. Feeding these technology
platforms are fields of biology where research is rapidly advancing.
In addition, two articles are entirely devoted to business issues.
To give you a taste of the articles,
I have summarized here the topics to be discussed and some of
the most salient statements to be found in the articles.
Business
Business models in biotech
* companies with technology platforms
that address only a tiny part of the drug discovery process risk
becoming optional or redundant accessories;
* there is no long-term business opportunity based on a narrow
technology platform that can support today's valuations of several
hundred to a few billion dollars;
* the ability of a biotech company to leverage its platforms
into multiple projects and sell the same outputs more than once
in different packages is likely to give rise to a good business;
Competitive business intelligence
gathering and analysis
* intelligence systems are providing
an answer to the avalanche of information in science and business
Diseases
Autoimmune diseases
* rapid progress in our understanding
of immune function promises more effective treatments for autoimmune
disorders;
* the advent of large amounts of genomic information is enabling
a systematic attempt at correlating homologies between pathogens,
such as viruses and bacteria, and specific self-proteins
Asthma
* with asthma cases on the rise,
a better understanding of the disease on the molecular and systems
levels promises more efficacious treatments;
* asthma is a multifactorial disease with multiple potential
drug targets, whose therapeutic potential remains to be resolved;
Arthritis
* the ageing populations of developed
countries are likely to present a growing market for arthritis
therapies;
* arthritis is now a disease that is fought with many drugs.
On the whole, these drugs treat inflammation as a symptom, but
do not address the actual cause of the disease;
* increasing understanding of the molecular cascades involved
are already producing significantly better drugs than in the
past with increased selectivity and fewer side effects;
Cardiovascular disease
* prognostic/diagnostic testing
and a raft of new drug targets from genomics promise to transform
cardiovascular medicine;
* in addition to improved surgical procedures and drugs, cardiovascular
medicine is beginning to make use of the flood of genomic information
emerging from tissue specific sequencing projects;
Cancer multidrug resistance
* progress in understanding the
molecular basis of drug resistance in cancer promises more effective
treatments;
* there are probably other multidrug resistance inducing molecules
in cancer cells that have yet to be characterized, including
ones that belong to the MDR-1 and MRP protein superfamilies;
* cancer defends itself actively by using resistance-mediating
transporter mechanisms, and therefore their impairment is likely
to have a significant therapeutic benefit;
Malaria
* together with major international
initiatives, companies are launching an offense against the world's
most deadly parasitic diease;
* malaria is a curable disease if promptly diagnosed and adequately
treated. In addition, significant lessening of its effects and
spread can be accomplished by preventive measures;
Antibacterial and antifungal
drug discovery
Companies are racing to keep
pace with the emergence of drug-resistant micro-organisms;
HIV
* the need for new treatments
for AIDS is more urgent than ever;
* AIDS has attracted vast resources from governments, universities
and industry the world over for the single purpose of controlling,
preventing, and ultimately curing the disease;
* more than 100 new medicines against AIDS are currently being
tested;
Technologies
Bioinformatics
* companies are selling research
software to a small number of rich clients or offering services
to researchers over the Internet;
* the market appears to be significant and growing rapidly, driven
partly by a focus on genomics, pharmacogenomics, biochips;
* integration of data acquisition, storage, manipulation, analysis
and dissemination in a cross-platform manner, unambiguous gene
sequence assignment, and development and application of new language
and ontology-based approaches are all at the leading edge of
the field;
Data mining
* software and services are developed
to analyze complex biological and chemical data in an intuitive
and efficient manner
* data mining is emerging within the biopharmaceutcial industry
as a significant ally in the analysis of biological data sets
in a way that compliments and expands traditional bioinformatics;
Signal transduction
* mapping the key signaling molecules
in biochemical pathways will be central to future drug discovery
efforts;
* all major pharmaceutical and biotechnology companies have active
drug discovery programs based on understanding signal transduction
pathways
Pharmacogenomics
* information on human genetic
variance is only just beginning to be used in drug development;
* the greatest challenge by the pharmacogenomics industry is
the systematic correlation between normal versus disease patterns
of gene expression in a statistically meaningful way;
* drugs that are more specific, not only in terms of the particular
molecule they target, but also in the populations they affect,
will be much more widely accepted and used in the future, and
initial applications may revolve around infectious diseases
Biochips
* with products already on the
market, biochips are likely to have an increasing impact on genetic
diagnostics, drug discovery, and basic research applications
Proteomics
* by globally catalogueing cellular
protein content and state, proteomics promises to complement
genomics in drug discovery and basic research
Lead validation platforms
* a battery of screening systems
are under development to validate compounds for further development;
* the key lead validation challenge is the development of high-throughput
screens that also provide clinically useful information. Inevitably,
there is a trade-off between the ease and speed of a test, and
value of the information given;
* it will be a synthesis of the information derived from as many
of these screening techniques as possible that will provide the
most important insights into the behaviour of a lead in a clinical
setting;
Combinatorial chemistry
* to avoid becoming a commodities
industry, combinatorial chemistry companies are broadening their
technology base;
Xenotransplantation
* work to combat immune rejection
is progressing, concerns remain as to the risks of disease transmission;
* the final challenge to the development of xenotransplantation
as a viable therapy is the prospect of novel infections, particularly
viral ones, being introduced through the recipient into the human
population;
* society's need, in conjunction with clinical efforts and corporate
interest in this area, promise to keep xenotransplantation in
the limelight as a technology to watch;
Tissue engineering
* despite technical and regulatory
challenges, the prospects for tissue engineering are good;
* tissue engineering is emerging as a vibrant industry with a
huge potential market
Source: Nature Biotechnology Vol 18 Supplement 2000. The ACTIP
Secretariat may be approached for a copy of the publication.
And some more
predictions:
The golden age
of pharmaceutical industry
Randy Scott, president of Incyte
Genomics, predicts that in 2010 the molecular basis for most
major diseases will be understood, resulting in numerous new
targets for the pharmaceutical industry. His predictions include:
* 2000: every gene sequenced;
* 2001: every EST on a chip;
* 2002: all frequent coding SNPs identified;
* 2002: a full length cDNA for every gene;
* 2005: virtually every signaling pathway identified;
* 2007: a chemical compound that effects most major signaling
pathways;
* 2010: understanding the molecular basis for most major diseases?
An interesting article, available
from the ACTIP Secretariat
Source: Conceptuur, no 24, Sept 2000
The
Future of Genomics in Europe
In the beginning of November,
a 2-day conference, organized by the Life Sciences High Level
Group of Experts (advicers to Commissoner Busquin), was held
in Brussels. There were sessions on Human Health, Food Integrity
& Supply, Valuing Biodiversity and Responsible Use of Genomics.
Below you will find my own (Helma Hermans') interpretation of
key points mentioned during the two day conference. Please note
that I do not refer to one single speaker, but have mixed my
notes from different presentations.
The challenges
Three challenges of genome technologies
could be identified: scientific, economic and cultural
(1) scientific:
* the human genome project's current and future tasks: finalize
the sequence (fill in the gaps & confirm), find predisposing
sequence variations, search for function (biological goals, biochemical
activities, cellular structures);
* the technologies: bioinformatics, transcriptomics, proteomics,
two-hybrid systems;
* the need: the EU needs centers of excellence in gene therapy;
* we should strive for 'science with dignity'
(2) economic:
* Europe is catching up with the US in terms of number of biotechnology
start up companies, but the US still invests much more in R&D
and the companies have more employees;
* Europe needs an innovation culture which requires excellence
in science;
* the benefit of genomics is diffuse and the cost potentially
great;
* genomics will probably be a case where individual benefits
outweigh social costs;
(3) cultural:
* as a society we have to take responsible decisions, and we
have responsibility for new norms;
* science should be brought into the collective conscience;
* responsible use of genetics is about avoiding abuse/misuse
and about promising benefits;
* the genetic revolution happens in a much more public arena
than other scientific revolutions;
* the Eurobarometer study clearly shows that people do not trust
industry and government;
* public hesitancy in accepting (some) new technologies has little
to do with public understanding of facts;
* there are concerns about gene becoming a danger word:
(1) reluctance of scientists to explain what they are up to -
genetics is too important to be left to experts;
(2) very negative portrayal of the life sciences in fiction (X-files,
Jurassic Park, Frankenstein) - journalism is driven by entertainment,
not information;
(3) the yuk-factor;
* with genomics we come on the
slippery slope of genetic screening, gender choice, embryo selection,
genetic manipulation, cloning;
* genetic testing will take the
form of diagnostics (disorders), presymptomatic screening (family
history), screening of healthy carriers (reproductive, preventive)
and predictive (about increased or reduced chances to get a disease);
* genetic information should be private;
* people who are different should be valued;
* genomics will pave the way for the phenomenon of the 'unpatient';
Regulatory
news
Supporting the use of
embryonic cells
Dutch government has drafted
a proposal for an act in which human embryonic cells should be
allowed for medical and biological research. However, embryos
should not be grown specifically for that purpose; only ova and
embryos left over from in vitro fertilization attempts can be
used. The proposal still needs to be debated. Therapeutic cloning
will not be possible.
Source: Wetvoorstel inzake handelingen met geslachtscellen
en embryo's: http://www.volkskrant.nl/nieuws/den_haag/350033953.html?history=/i335020922
Workshop on certification
of suitability for TSE risk products
Jan 11, 2001, Strasbourg,
France
The EDQM is pleased to invite
all interested parties to a workshop so that you may become more
familiar with the contribution of the TSE certification procedure.
This certification procedure is intended to demonstrate compliance
to the amended EU Directives 75/318/EEC for human products and
81/852 EEC for veterinary products, and with the status of the
procedure. The content and preparation of the dossiers will be
dealt with, as well as some specific cases (gelatin, tallow derivatives
etc.)
This workshop is especially intended for manufacturers or users
of biological substances and excipients in industry. It will
emphasize the practical aspects of making up dossiers.
Pestivirus contaminations
of bovine sera and other bovine viruses contaminations
Paris, March 29-30,
2001
The EDQM also organizes a two-day
meeting to clarify the technical and regulatory questions surrounding
sourcing, production, testing and use of bovine sera. In addition
to scientific and technical presentations and discussions, the
last part will focus mainly on the detection and inactivation
of methods in order to propose recommendations in this field.
For both the workshop and the 2-day meeting, extensive information
is available from the ACTIP Secretariat or from EDQM (Caroline
le Tarnec, tel + 33 3 88 41 28 15).
Drug firms want speedier approval procedures
EU pharmaceutical firms have called on Enterprise Commissioner
Erkki Liikanen to streamline the current drug approval process,
claiming it is preventing vital medicines from reaching the market
quickly. The demand comes as the European Commision is preparing
plans to restructure EMEA. According to EFPIA, EMEAs performance
has been excellent, with the organization living up to its promise
to report on new applications within 210 days. However, the required
consultation round with all EU member states add an average 90
days to getting a medicine authorized. According to EFPIA, the
bureaucracy is the problem. Red tape is also clogging up the
procedure of 'mutual recognition', a procedure which does not
seem to work at all.
Source: European Voice, October 18, 2000
Research
news
In-utero immunization
technique
Reseachers of the Veterinary
Infectious Disease Organization at the University of Saskatchewan
have developed a method for inoculating livestock in utero. The
same method could also be used to vaccinate human babies against
viral diseases such as herpes simplex, hepatitis B, human cytomegalovirus,
and group B streptococcus, all of which are most frequently contracted
from the mother during or shortly after birth. The researchers
injected fetal lambs with a DNA vaccine for bovine herpesvirus-1.
The vaccine caused the lambs to produce mucosal antibodies to
the virus, but otherwise they developed normally during gestation
and after birth.
Source: Canadian Biotech News, Sep 11, 2000 http://www.canadianbiotechnews.com
Alpha-glucosidase keeps
babies alive
A recent publication in The Lancet
demonstrates how treatment with alpha-glucosidase has kept 4
babies with Pompe's disease already alive for more than one yera.
Their muscles have become stronger and the heart muscle functions
better. The children will have to use the product for the rest
of their lives. Depending on clinical tests, Pharming hopes to
register the drug at the end of 2001.
Gene technology with
laser pulse
Researchers at the US Beckman
Laser Institute have developed an innovative method to knock
out genes. They used a two-photon laser microscope to direct
a very narrow, high energetic laser pulse on a previously selected
part of a chromosome. The chromosome was coloured with a fluorescent
dye, making it sensitive to the laser light. With this technique
they succeeded in knocking out a number of ribosomal genes in
Potorous tridactylis, a marsupial with extremely flat cells in
cell culture. Source: PNAS 97 (17): 9504.
Support for EU plant
research in europe plummets downward
Support for plant science research
by the European Union has been dropping sharply. In FP5 there
has been a two-thirds reduction in the number of successful plant
research proposals funded by the EU. Dutch authorities are in
the midst of implementing a 30% cut of plant research funding
over 5 years and have ended funding for all collaborative projects.
All Danish programs in plant biotechnology will expire by 2002,
and no new initiatives are planned. According to Nature Biotechnology
(18, pg.919) Italy's Green minister for agriculture and forestry,
Alfonso Pecoraro Scanio, is pushing Italian agbiotech research
to the point of collapse. There has been a 75% cut of financial
resources for research inside the agriculture ministry in the
last two years. In addition GM field trials have fallen from
about 40 in 1999 to 26 this year. "The precautionary principle
is turning out to be a 'no experimentation principle',"
says Roberto Defez. In practice, this means a halt to research,
whether in applied sectors or in biosafety.
Source: 31/8/2000 ; ref: PK2091
GM tomato rsv antigen
vaccine
University of Illinois scientists
report in the Eur. J. Transgenic Research on a tomato derived
edible vaccine and tests. The scientists used the expressed major
protein on the outside envelope of the respiratory syncytial
virus. Increased antibody production in the mucosal and serum
immune systems of mice was observed when fed five times with
GM tomatoes. Source: 2/8/2000 ; ref: AN2042
Business
news
Delays in implementing
biotechnology patenting directive
By June 2000, the EU biotechnology
patenting directive should have been implemented in the EU member
states. As per September 2000, it was only implemented in Denmark,
Finland, Ireland, and the UK. The directive is under discussion
or in the form of a draft proposal in Austria, Belgium, France,
Germany, Greece, Italy, Spain, Sweden, and The Netherlands.
Source: CEFIC/FEBC, personal
communication
Patent application human/animal
embryos withdrawn
Under pressure of Greenpeace,
companies Australian Stem Cell Sciences and US BioTransplant
have withdrawn their patent application covering technologies
to create human embryos using animal cells. The patent application
covered the transfer of the nucleus of one species to the cell
of another, creating i.e. a human nucleus into an enucleated
pig ovum. A 32-cell embryo was the result. Nuclear transfer is
potentially of interest in the cultivation of tissues and organs
for xenotransplantation.
Source: http://www.sunday-times.co.uk; http://www.greenpeace.org;
http://www.informagen.com/Resource_Informagen/Full/8252.html;
Patent application: http://l2.espacenet.com/dips/viewer?PN=WO9921415&CY=ep&LG=en&DB=EPD
.... and a new Xenotransplant
company
Biotechnology companies Novartis
and BioTransplant have announced the establishment of a joint
company, to be based in Boston, for the development of xenotransplantation.
BioTransplant is active in the development of systems reducing
immune rejection and works on both allo- and xenotransplants.
Novartis will contribute Cambridge-based subsidiary Imutran.
Source: BioTransplant: http://www.corporate-ir.net/ireye/ir_site.zhtml?ticker=btrn&script=410&layou
t=7&item_id=119262
High cell density bioreactor
with ultrafast on-line dsp
Computer Cell Culture Center
was set up in 1989 by our good friend, prof. Alain Miller. In
March 1999, the company raised 150 million Bfrs in a private
placement.
Based on the concepts developed by its founder, 4C has improved
and implemented a number of original technologies to achieve
mammalian cell cultures at high densities, which is claimed to
have a dramatic impact on production and product development
costs. For the future, 4C envisions development in 4 areas:
* production and sales of research biologicals;
* contracted GMP production;
* contracted process development;
* proprietary biotherapeutics; bioartificial organs
A recent patent application covers integration of high cell density
bioreactor operation with ultra fast on-line downstream processing.
Please contact prof. Miller or the ACTIP Secretariat if you are
interested in more details: Prof. Alain Miller, 4C, tel + 32
64 52 05 60, fax + 32 64 55 86 17. web:
www.4c.be
|